You Win Some, You Lose Some

Posted 18 September 2010 at 11:02 PM | Comments (9)

Graphic design, like any creative business, is a lot of work; in part because the possibilities are limitless and making small improvements can go on forever. In college I was undisciplined with editing and found myself sitting alone in the computer lab after 3:00 am every night. (I’m sure that all of you writers, filmmakers, photographers, etc. know exactly what I’m talking about.)

After ten years in the business, I’ve learned when to stop. I’ve learned which projects require more time and which require less; which require more research on the backend and which require more action on the front; and, perhaps the most valuable skill, I’ve learned how to work fast—especially when I’m not getting paid.

I recently entered a book cover design contest where working fast was essential, mostly because I was on the verge of going into labor but also because my instinct told me my style didn’t match the author’s intent. I wondered if I should enter the contest at all, but since it presented yet another opportunity for my unemployed, stay-at-home-mom ass to get a design workout, I went ahead and created a contest entry anyway:

Book Cover Design Contest Entry

The author had some interesting requirements. He felt it important for the book cover to have images of people, money, or open doors and to suggest attraction; yet he didn’t want images of fish or boats (see book title). So, one of my challenges was to come up with a design concept that was relevant to the book title without being overly literal. My solution? Turn dollar signs into “fish” and show them attracted to, and enthusiastically swimming upstream toward, “your boat.”

Another dilemma was the lengthy, almost confusing, book title. How do I get someone to stop and read the entire title and understand what the book is about? There were several solutions here. One was to keep the text clean and legible, and another was to highlight words that needed emphasis. Also, since the book’s subheading, as opposed to the title, makes it much clearer that it’s a marketing book, it was important for me to create a visual relationship between the two blocks of text, hence the swimming dollar signs that move your eye from top to bottom. I was also able to emphasize the subheading with a lighter blue background but didn’t make it so bold that it steals the show from the book’s title.

Lastly, it’s a marketing book, so it’s important for the book cover to convey a sense of authority as well as look up-to-date. Thus I was very careful not to use imagery or type treatments that would make the whole thing hokey; everything is very clean, strong, and midway between modern and classic.

I didn’t win the contest.

I’m perfectly alright with that, for two reasons. One, that’s the risk I take with design contests. I’m aware that my chances of winning are slim. Two, since I understood that risk involved, I didn’t let myself spend a lot of time on this project. I only allowed myself to go as far as I needed to create something good. Could it have been better? Heck, yeah. It could have been a whole lot better.

This is the design that won:

Book Cover Design Contest Winner

9 Responses to You Win Some, You Lose Some

  1. Natascha says:

    Well yours in way much better!!! I can’t believe that design won 🙁 It is not as attractive and clean as yours! Interesting…

  2. Jeanine says:

    What are those things on the other person’s design…mummies? They look funky. I like yours, but I must admit I am biased!

  3. Vidya says:

    Yours is very good but I think the color made a difference here. Even it’s a marketing book, the other person used some attractive color that will catch someone’s attention immediately. Best of luck for your other projects dear

  4. Kasha says:

    You are kidding me? Am I right? I can’t believe that you lost…

  5. negeen says:

    the good thing about losing to something so ugly is knowing that the judge has no taste. are you kidding me with those hands?

  6. Andrea Goto says:

    Hrrrmmph! I will NEVER read that book. That’ll teach ’em.

    I feel your pain. Submitting to literary journals is a similar experience. In fact, I just submitted one this morning. My chances are good–it’s the Graduate journal at SCAD. I like to pad my chances.

  7. Mojan says:

    Natascha: It didn’t surprise me, actually. I was pretty certain, from the get-go, that I wasn’t going to win this one.

    Jeanine: HA! Thanks for making me laugh.

    Vidya: You may be right. Either way, the author had to choose something that suited his taste best.

    Kasha: Nope, I’m not kidding! There were some other very good designs submitted. I’m curious what made him choose this one.

    Negeen: 🙂

    Andrea: Hey, good thinking. If I could think of a way to pad my chances, I would.

  8. Christie Szili says:

    Seriously, though… are those mummies!?! Great job, Mo! I’m so proud of you 🙂

  9. Mojan says:

    Ha, thanks Christie!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *